Ministry & Leadership

Preachers, Take That Hobbyhorse Out To Pasture5 min read

June 13, 2014 4 min read


Preachers, Take That Hobbyhorse Out To Pasture5 min read

Reading Time: 4 minutes

Sam and Veronica, a young couple, are expecting their first child in the next few months. They are scared, because in the last 2 years they have had two miscarriages.

Jennifer, now in her late 40’s, recently lost her husband to another woman and is now suffering through an ugly divorce process. To make matters worse, the elders have largely been uninvolved in the situation, leaving her all alone to deal with the consequences of her husband’s sin.

Charles and Donna just found out that their 5-year-old grandson has been diagnosed with cancer. They wish to help more with the situation, but his family lives 12 hours away.

Jacob, a senior in high school, thinks he might be gay, but is afraid to talk to anyone at church about the temptation because he knows he might be labeled and written off.

James and Melissa have their hands full raising four children, all under the age of 10.

Sharon is the sole caretaker of her father who has dementia. No one is offering to help her.

Andrea is a beautiful 35-year-old divorced mom who was abused. Her situation is such that she has no Scriptural right to re-marry and has to raise her children alone by herself.

Megan, a sophomore in college, is in a serious relationship with one of her classmates. She thinks he may soon ask her to marry him. She is uneasy about this, however, because he seldom comes to church (even though his parents regularly attend a sister congregation).

Frank, now in his late 70’s, is still grieving the loss of his wife who died 6 months ago. Next week would have been their 50th wedding anniversary.

All Of These People Are At Your Church

On Sunday morning, all of these people will come to the church building to worship their Creator. Yes, they may have different names and the details of their unique life situations may be different, but rest assured they are there. Adding to this complexity is the fact that they are all at different stages of spiritual maturity. Some grew up in the church; others were converted at various stages of life.

And now you, the preacher, have been charged with the weighty responsibility of regularly preaching to these people. What topic are you going to preach about for the 10th time this year? Denominationalism? Morality? Grace? Sin?

I try to remind myself of the magnitude of problems and issues the audience is facing whenever I prepare a sermon. This is a sobering exercise, especially for a young preacher like myself. I can’t help but ask myself, “What can I possibly say that will help Sam & Veronica, Jennifer, Sharon, Andrea, Frank, and everyone else?

And then I remember that there is nothing I can possibly say that is worth their time. My life is different than theirs. My advice, wisdom, and experience is woefully inadequate to meet the spiritual and emotional needs of the audience. They don’t need to listen to me. What Sam & Veronica, Jennifer, Sharon, Andrea, Frank, and the rest of the audience needs – more than anything else – is a message straight from God’s Word. God intended for His people to be encouraged on to greater faithfulness through “the foolishness of preaching” (1 Cor. 1:21). And the preacher must make that happen (Rom. 10:14).

Therefore, preachers should fight the urge to bring hobbyhorses into the pulpit. Far too often, preachers present topical sermons about the issues they care about on the topics they think are important at the neglect of the rest of God’s Word.

Are Your Sermons Mostly Topical Or Expository?

Are you doing the congregation a favor when most of your sermons are topical in nature, comprised almost entirely of anecdotes and textual references that have been pieced together from every corner of the Bible? Is the church benefiting in the long-run when a vast majority of your lessons are three-point, cleverly alliterated sermons that touch on only a handful of basic topics (i.e. “grace,” “denominationalism,” “worship,”) throughout the year?

I know what I am saying should be understood with balance. But as Denny Petrillo once said, “Preachers should have to earn the right to preach topically.” I understand what he means. Instead of relying entirely on my own [naïve] judgment, I try to semi-systematically preach through the Bible with expository sermons. Mark Dever defines expository preaching as preaching that “exposes God’s Word to God’s people, that opens it up to them and applies it to their hearts so that they may understand it and obey it” (36).

Expository preaching says, “God knows better than I do about what this congregation needs to hear, so I am going to let Him say it.” If preachers dedicate themselves to primarily preaching the Text, rather than preaching only topical sermons, they will avoid the mistake of hobbyhorse preaching.

Of course there is a time and place for topical sermons. The church needs to hear lessons about denominationalism, baptism, repentance, marriage & divorce, worship, and morality (and shame on you if you do not regularly address these topics). But at some point the pulpit must go beyond these topics (cf. Heb. 6:1).

The congregation has far too many needs for you to meet from the pulpit alone. Take the burden off your shoulders by allowing God to speak through you. Expose the Word. Be the messenger, not the author. In due time, the needs of the congregation will be addressed in balance.

What every person in the audience on Sunday morning needs more than anything else is the Word of God. It gives direction (Psa. 119:105), offers comfort (107), equips you to overcome temptation (11), and gives zeal (139). I cannot improve on that.

Works Cited
Dever, Mark. Preach: Theology Meets Practice. B&H Publishing Group: Nashville, TN. 2012.
Petrillo, Denny. “Unashamed Workmen: Principles of Biblical Exegesis.” Focal Point 2014 Lectures. University church of Christ: San Marcos, TX.

Ben Giselbach is the pulpit minister at the Edgewood church of Christ in Columbus, GA. He and his wife Hannah have two children, Ezra & Colleyanna. Ben is a graduate of Freed-Hardeman University and has returned to pursue his MDiv. He has written three books in his You Are A Theologian Series: Thinking Right about the Bible, Thinking Right about God, and Thinking Right about Salvation.
  1. Tyler

    Convicting stuff, and a sobering reminder for all of those who take the pulpit. We need to become less, while God becomes greater (John 3:30), otherwise we may be the reason "the cross of Christ be emptied of its power" because of what we think is wise or eloquent (1 Corinthians 1:17).

  2. Jon Mitchell

    I tell my preaching school students that they need to keep track of all subjects they preach, regardless of whether they got those subjects through topical or expository methods, and every week look back over the previous month's worth of sermons and see if there have been any "repeats" in any way. If there have, then next week a completely new subject needs to be addressed.

  3. Will

    And someone who believes it so much that he relentlessly follows it with out questioning it. holding on to the confidence he has in it there for he does not shrink when living the word of God. They need to see us as preachers denying ourselves for the sake of the Lord. Paul always used his example as a foundation of his teaching the word of God. Follow me as I follow Christ.

  4. Jon Mitchell

    I also tell my students to be in the homes of brethren, befriending them as best they can. This results in observing what's going in in that Christian's life, and them also trusting you enough to come to you for advice. That lets the preacher know of other topics he needs to address from the pulpit or in one-on-one Bible study.

  5. Denise

    Ben, I agree, the best thing a preacher can do is, "Preach the word!" Study, be sure you are preaching God's word and not your own. :) God will be the one to convict and change hearts, minds. . . we as Christian's are his tools. He will use us as He pleases. (A preacher's wife perspective.)

  6. Tommy O'Kelley

    I have found it is very important to stay in touch with the members to include the young people ans as situations come up they can be discussed or preached on I also have a sermon suggestion box in the foyer with the information sheet and encourage individuals to fill them out and place in the box. I will then go through them and will announce when I will be preaching that lesson or lessons. If there are just questions I will take a Sunday night and spend time addressing those questions. Great thoughts Ben

  7. jennifersawyer

    Yes, what you preach is important. But more important is your investment in the lives of people. Your tears as you stand with a family at midnight faced with removing a loved one from life support become the filter through which they hear everything you say from the pulpit. I guess that's part of "earning the right."

  8. Brian

    I think you got it exactly right, Ben. I would add that, ideally, the elders would be first in the homes of the brethren getting to know them personally and actually shepherding. Sadly, too often, that responsibility is passed off to the preacher.

  9. […] Preachers Take That Hobby Horse Out to Pasture, Plain Simple Faith […]

  10. happyhealthyholyhome

    I shared this article to provide extra reading on my most recent post. Thank you so much for this! Very well put.

Comments are closed.

Leave a comment